In Ketosis but Not Losing Weight? These Foods May be Stalling Your Progress

Foods that Cause Weight Loss Stalls and Plateaus

Stop Stalling Volume Two: Malignant Mouthfuls

Welcome back to the Stop Stalling series! Today, we’re going to take a look at some specific foods that may be causing your stall. These foods may be keeping you from getting ahead. The bad news is that a lot of them may be staples for you. Many of them seem keto-friendly: they’re low in net carbs and should be “safe.” In fact, they are “safe” for plenty of people. However, for some people, certain foods can cause stalls. If you’re in ketosis but not losing weight and have implemented everything advised in Volume 1: Operator Error, here’s a list of the most likely suspects.

In Ketosis but Not Losing Weight? These Foods May be Stalling Your Progress

Dairy:

Dairy is a tricky one. First of all, it’s very energy-dense (i.e. it has a lot of calories). That means that it can be really easy to overdo. Alas, keto isn’t magical, and calories still count. Secondly, it’s often a carbohydrate bomb. A glass of milk has about ten grams. It can have more or less depending on the fat content. It can be tough to tell with yogurt: while the actual carb count is probably lower than what is listed on the label (fermentation consumes some of the carbohydrates), you can’t always tell just how many there are. This is even ignoring the fact that many yogurts contain additives, including starch-based thickeners. Finally, dairy is especially prone to “rounding down”: even though many labels say that a serving of cheese contains zero carbohydrates, chances are that a serving contains as many as 0.7 grams.

It seems like very little, but if you eat two servings (easy to do!), it’s going to add up over time. Many people rely on dairy, and when they drop it, they start losing again.

Seeds and nuts:

Seeds and nuts are horrible bastards. I love nuts, especially almonds. Especially the smoked ones or the spicy ones. And nut butter? Don’t get me started. I can eat half a jar of it in one sitting. I HAVE eaten half a jar (and then some) in one sitting. Do you see where I’m going with this? If not, here’s the spoiler: I can’t keep nut butter in the house because it’s a trigger food for me. I can only buy seeds and nuts in single-serve packages, and even then it’s not advisable. Seeds and nuts are good sources of protein and fat, but they also contain carbohydrates, many of which are sugar and starch and therefore anti-ketogenic. They contain a surprising amount of carbohydrates, actually. Even macademias, which are the most keto-friendly of the bunch, contain about 3 grams in a 2-oz. serving. This wouldn’t be a problem, except that it’s really easy to overeat them. A serving is way less than you think, so all of a sudden, your snack just blew your carb count for the day. Many people find that their stalls go away when they stop eating nuts.

Maltitol:

This one’s sad. Very sad, because sugar-free candies seem like such a great way to deal with cravings. You want a Forbidden Treat? If you can find a sugar-free version, no problem, right? Alas, that is very, very wrong. Maltitol is a sugar alcohol, so it does have zero net carbs. However, its glycemic index is 52 for syrup and 36 for powdered. It will cause an insulin response, and it will impact blood glucose. (About half of the calories in maltitol can be absorbed.) Cut the grams of maltitol in your food in half and pretend that it’s table sugar, and you’ll have a pretty good idea of why maltitol is not at all good for people trying to maintain ketosis.

If that’s not enough of a deterrent, consider that maltitol has a laxative effect. Yes, many babes will eat a couple of sugar-free candies when the train is a little bit late leaving the station. Sometimes, this works well. Sometimes, they wind up with a bullet train that leaves without making a last call. (That’s where we get “disaster pants” and why so many women don’t trust keto farts.) Shart roulette is an even crappier game than carb chicken.

Fat bombs:

People often ask, “Why do you hate BPC?” Well, I personally hate BPC because I think coffee tastes vile and is probably the devil’s beverage. (Just kidding. Sort of.) But that’s not what you mean. You’re wondering why Ketogasm and KBB discourage the use of BPC and fat bombs. This is where it gets more complicated. If you are using the ketogenic diet as part of a weight loss program, you should not be going out of your way to eat or drink more calories, whether they are carb-y or not. It is NOT necessary to maintain a ketogenic ratio* for weight loss, and doing so could be a bit part of why you’re stalling.

Remember the motto “Carbs are a limit, protein is a goal, fat is a lever”? That’s what we mean: you should definitely not go above your carbs, you should definitely try to hit your protein, but you absolutely do not need to hit your fat macro. Making it a goal is going to hurt your progress. If you are stalling, try to cut back on your fat a bit. Don’t go below 50 or 60 grams a day of ingested fat (you need dietary fat to absorb certain nutrients, avoid feeling like crap, and maintain skin and hair health), but unless you’re hungry or having trouble focusing, there’s no need to ingest extra fat: your body will “eat” from its stores.

*A ketogenic ratio is used for people who are treating neurological conditions like epilepsy with a ketogenic diet. In this case, a certain ratio of macronutrients is necessary to prevent seizures. In this case, people must make sure that they eat enough fat to supply their ketones. This type of therapeutic diet is not used for weight loss; it is used to suppress symptoms of an illness. Even if you have more ketones circulating while eating more fat, you will not be burning your own fat stores. This is also why we say no to exogenous ketones.

Alcohol:

Drinking alcohol on the keto diet can indeed cause your weight to stall. Be sure to read the keto alcohol guide to understand exactly why this could be contributing to your lack of progress.

Non-keto foods:

This one is bound to ruffle some feathers. Heck, I didn’t like to hear it. There are those of us who are tempted to eat non-keto foods in small amounts, hoping that if it fits our macros, it won’t throw us out of ketosis. There are those of us who can. There are those of us who can’t. There are those of us who can have some non-keto foods in small amounts but not others. Nevertheless, if you’ve been eating small amounts of non-keto foods and hoping that you’re still maintaining ketosis, well, you might want to stop. You see, there are several problems with doing this. Just as you’ve learned that not all calories are the same and that not all carbs are the same, you’ve hopefully learned that not all sources of sugar, starch, fiber, etc. are the same. This kind of sucks, because it makes things confusing. Let’s take sugar, for example. A teaspoon of table sugar might seem like it would affect you the same way that 4 g of sugar in a handful of raspberries would, but it doesn’t. It isn’t tempered with water and fiber the way raspberries are. The same is true for honey. While it may be paleo, it sure as hell isn’t keto.

The Ketogenic Diet goes beyond helping adherents maintain ketosis: it also helps reduce inflammation and maintain general health. Non-keto foods don’t help with that. They can also promote inflammation, which can indeed result in weight gain (or a lack of weight loss). Cutting inflammatory foods may be the key.
In the third and final installment of Stop Stalling, we’ll look at underlying medical conditions that could be causing you to struggle with weight loss. Keto on, babes!

Don’t forget to PIN it!

In ketosis but not losing weight? These foods may be causing you to stall!

Julia is a teacher, tutor, and educational advisor who resides in Washington State, inconveniently close to Woodinville, where one finds many of the local wineries. She has a deep and abiding love for cats, cheese, spicy food, and pickled things. She someday hopes to take over the world, but in the meantime, is looking into public health. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram @SWFgoesketo, where she often posts pictures of food and the gym.

JOIN THE KETOGASM SQUAD!

Say YES to your health! Get the latest recipes, tips, and resources delivered directly to your inbox!

Powered by ConvertKit

7 Comments

  • Thanks Julia. I've started hosting low carb weight loss challenges and for people reporting stall outs, they commonly cite cheese, nuts, dark chocolate and pepperonis as the snacks they might be overconsuming to the point that their low carb diet is no longer working.
  • I have only just started, day four for me, have been very careful at calculating and keeping on point. I seem to be more bloated and have lost exactly no weight :( Any advice gratefully received!! I'm feeling very disheartened. I am not looking to keep up fat, just hit my protein target and not going over my carbs. I am exercising. My body fat is 22%. I am sticking to 20 net carbs.
    • It took almost 2 weeks of keto dieting before I started seeing/feeling a change. And then it was dramatic for a while. I lost 27 lbs over the course of about 5 weeks, which is a lot. Then I plateaued for a while (about 3 weeks) and now I'm starting to see a gradual loss again of about 2-3 lbs per week. I was at a significantly higher body fat, being at a 30.9%, so that probably accounts for the fast loss at the beginning. Now that I'm nearer my goal, it's more gradual. Just keep it up, it will happen. And maybe look at adjusting your carbs. 20 net carbs is quite low, maybe up it to 25 net carbs and see if that helps? You don't want too many carbs on a keto diet, but too few can have an opposite effect.
  • Thank you so much for providing this.. and for free! Hopefully this will help me out of my rut. It feels a little bit like I'm back to square one now though.. if I need to be careful how much protein I have.. what do you eat?
  • Thank so much for the thorough post and tips! I've recently hit a stall, and some members of the keto group I belong to pointed out that I might be overdoing it on some of these things. This post helped me home down on exactly what kinds of things I need to cut out of my keto diet. I'll try to report back in a couple of weeks on my progress, and whether or not I was able to break my "stall".
  • Thanks so much for this perspective. I just started keto for the main purpose of weightloss. I have done BPC for two days, and just hate the idea of drinking so many calories! I'd much prefer to eat grass-fed butter on steamed veggies or some other keto food that will fill me up. You've saved me some heartache!
  • Hello, I'm so confused now because I'm on a few keto Facebook posts and most of them promote fat bombs and BPC. I never understood why you had to add more fat than what's already in a low carb/ keto diet. What you're saying makes more sense to me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *